Home About Contact Policies Reviews Challenges Giveaways Image Map

Which Cover? #8

Hi everyone! There hasn't seemed to be too many cover changes lately, but here are the ones I've seen:

The Innocents by Lili Peloquin

The Innocents (The Innocents, #1)The Innocents

My Thoughts: Older- It better reflects the mystery in the plot and I like how it depicts the two sisters. I think the newer cover is kind of weird and doesn't tell you much about the book.

From What I Remember by Stacey Kramer and Valerie Thomas

From What I Remember...From What I Remember

My Thoughts: Older- It's more dramatic and I think their poses are awesome. The new cover seems kind of bland to me.

The Naturals by Jennifer Lynn Barnes

The Naturals

My Thoughts: Newer- This book isn't out yet, so it's just a cover change pre-release, but I like the new cover design a lot better. It's so unique and really stands out :)

Just One Day by Gayle Forman

Just One Day (Just One Day, #1)Just One Day

My Thoughts: Both- I think both covers are gorgeous! I love the covers for the newer one, but the older one is also super intriguing.

Which covers do you like better? :)


  1. Both of the Gayle Forman cover are gorgeous- I can't decide either.

    Thanks for sharing, hon! <33

  2. I am complete agreement with you. For the first one I like the older one, for the next one I like the newer one, and for the last one both are nice. :)

  3. I agree with you on all of them..although I think I like the original cover for Just one Day a tiny bit more :)

  4. The original covers are all better, except for the Naturals cover. I loved the original and the new one for Gayle Forma, but the original is always going to be my favorite.

  5. I agree! I like the original covers for The Innocents and From What I remember, but I like the new cover for The Naturals. It looks a lot more fun and eye-catching to me, and it kind of goes along with something that happens in the story too. I like both of the covers for Just One Day, but I'm really liking the pretty silhouettes/shadows/light on the new cover! :) Fun post!

    Alice @ Alice in Readerland

  6. I agree with all of your opinions on these :) The Innocents is such a brilliant cover. don't know why they changed it. And I was attracted to From What I Remember ONLY because of the cover -- it's pretty cool. The new one doesn't compare.

  7. I like the older ones for the first two, the newer for The Naturals and I love both for Just One Day! They are absolutely gorgeous! Great picks, Montana! :D

    ~ Maida
    Literary Love Affair 

  8. I always love cover comparison posts, and commenting with my choices.
    The Innocents by Lili Peloquin -- While I do like both covers, I like the older one better. The newer one just doesn't seem different, like the old one does.

    From What I Remember by Stacey Kramer and Valerie Thomas -- Unless the entire plot of this book is that 2 friends wake up together "The Morning After", and the girl announces she's pregnant, I have no use for the new cover at all. The old one is *blah*, too, but being better than that new one is easy-peasy.

    The Naturals by Jennifer Lynn Barnes -- Definitely the newer cover, since I find the look on the girl's face in the older one to be creepy/weird, and I find the police-wrapped box to be a unique idea.

    Just One Day by Gayle Forman -- Don't really like the new covers on this series. I like the old(er) cover quite a bit. Love how she looks like she's remininscing in her mind about deep things.


Hi! Thank you so much for commenting, I read each and every comment and love reading them :) Also, I'll comment back as soon as I can. Happy Reading!