Home About Contact Policies Reviews Challenges Giveaways Image Map

Which Cover? #9

Hi everyone! It's been a while since I've done a 
Which Cover? post. I'm hoping to do them more often and here are some of the recent cover changes I've found:

The Rules by Stacey Kade

The Rules (Project Paper Doll, #1)The Rules

My Opinion: Newer- I wasn't a fan of the original cover, and the new one is so much more unique and eye-catching! 

Out of the Easy by Ruta Sepetys

Out of the EasyOut of The Easy
My Opinion: Older-I love the colors on the original and the birdhouse is very cool! I would probably think Out of the Easy was an adult novel based on the second cover.

Lucid by Adrienne Stoltz and Ron Bass

My Opinion: Older- I'm pretty torn about this one, but I think the purple shade and upside down aspect of the cover make the older cover more appealing.

Send Me A Sign by Tiffany Schmidt

Send Me a SignSend Me a Sign
My Opinion: Older- The best I'd describe the older cover is it having kind of a whimsical feel to it and the newer cover seems more generic.

Which covers do you like better? :)


  1. I agree for The Rules! Seriously love the idea of it. I always loved the cover for Send Me A Sign, the new one looks horrible and generic IMO

    Thanks for sharing, Montana! <33

  2. This is interesting but with all these I go with older covers. I think The Rules can work with both as I don't like either. But if I had to pick then older. I love the cover of Send Me a Sign as it's unusual, while the new one cannot be more typical. Great picks :)

  3. For the first and last one, definitely the second cover. The third one I'm not so sure about. And the birdcage cover looks the best on the second one. I think it's my favorite out of all of them!

  4. The new The Rules cover is freaky but very interesting and eye-catching. I think I like it better. I like the older covers for the rest. :)

  5. I like the older on all of them. Lol. I am a bit on the fence about the Rules. I just love the blues and the gloomy of the older cover.

  6. I completely agree with all of your choices. I am also not really sure why they bothered changing Lucid, I love the purple and it is more catching to me.

  7. I love this feature! :) I really like what they did with The Rules cover (I'd be a lot more likely to pick it up now), but I'm really disappointed in what they did with the Out of the Easy cover. I really liked the first one!!!

    Alice @ Alice in Readerland

  8. I like both covers for Out of the Easy, though I know what you mean about the newer one seeming more adult. I think the old one is probably my favorite of the two though!!


  9. I don't mind either cover for Out of the Easy but I definitely prefer the older one more. I have a thing for birdhouses so it certainly suits my taste!

  10. Definitely the new cover for The Rules! I really like it a lot. Very different and eye-catching!
    Original Out of the Easy cover. It screams New Orleans, and it is the cover that was on the copy that I read, and I loved that book so much. So the cover will always be the one that I identify with this wonderful story!
    Lucid's original cover definitely fits the feeling and oddity of the book, so that one.
    The last books covers, both of them, are kind of blah. The second one looks like a ton of other YA/NA covers out there. So in that respect, I guess the older one.


Hi! Thank you so much for commenting, I read each and every comment and love reading them :) Also, I'll comment back as soon as I can. Happy Reading!