Home About Contact Policies Reviews Challenges Giveaways Image Map

Which Cover? #10

Hi everyone! Here's the newest edition of Which Cover?

The Lucy Variations by Sara Zarr
The Lucy VariationsThe Lucy Variations

My Opinion: Newer- Although the older cover does a better job at hinting about the plotline involving a piano player, the newer one is so much prettier and eye-catching! 

Carnival of Souls/Carnival of Secrets by Melissa Marr
Carnival of Secrets

My Opinion: Older- I'm not a huge fan of either cover, but the older one is bolder. The newer one looks pretty weird to me and it doesn't seem to give any indication to the plot.

Obsidian and Onyx by Jennifer Armentrout
Obsidian (Lux, #1)Onyx (Lux, #2)vs.Beginnings: Obsidian & Onyx (Lux, #1-2)
My Opinion: Older- I just really like the cover models for the Lux series. I think they fit the characters of Katy and Damon perfectly. On the new cover, Katy's the only character that stands out. I'm probably still going to buy a copy of it anyway, though :)
Level 2/The Memory of After by Lenore Appelhans
Level 2 (The Memory Chronicles, #1)The Memory of After (The Memory Chronicles, #1)

My Opinion: Both- Both covers are pretty similar, and I think both titles work well for the both. I like the color scheme better for the second, but the model's facial expression looks kind of odd.

Which covers do you like better? :)


  1. I agree with you on The Lucy Variations. While the original is cute and does a good job representing the story, I think the second one is just a lot more interesting to look at!

  2. I love this and I agree with you on all of them I don't like that you don't even really notice Damon in the new Lux covers.

  3. I like the font of the second version of The Lucy Variations! I haven't read any of these, but its interesting to see how different some covers end up being.

  4. I think I agree with all of your opinions. I definitely like the second one better for Lucy; stands out more.

  5. I like the older Lucy, the newer Lux, and the older Carnival. :)

  6. I like the old Lucy Variation cover. The Second one kind of looks like a bad instagram filter, imo.

  7. I really liked the old cover for Obsidian but Onyx and Opal just seemed too unorganized, so I'm happy about the new cover and the fact that they're merging two books into one :)

  8. I agree with you on all of these, except I'd go with the newer for Melissa Mar's book! It's so creepily fantastic :)


Hi! Thank you so much for commenting, I read each and every comment and love reading them :) Also, I'll comment back as soon as I can. Happy Reading!