Home About Contact Policies Reviews Challenges Giveaways Image Map

Which Cover? #11

Hi everyone! Here's the newest edition of Which Cover? Here are the recent cover changes that I've found:

Earthbound by Aprilynne Pike
Earthbound (Earthbound, #1)Earthbound

My Opinion: Older: Although nothing stands out too much about the older cover, the newer cover is kind of strange to me. The picture doesn't seem to match the description of the book, although it somewhat matches the title.

The Book of Broken Hearts by Sarah Ockler
The Book of Broken HeartsThe Book of Broken Hearts

My Opinion: Older: The older cover is so pretty and I love how the pages of the book form a heart. That is seriously one of the cutest ideas ever! However, the new cover looks cheesy and I wish they didn't change the original one. 

Dangerous Girls by Abigail Haas

Dangerous GirlsDangerous Girls

My Opinion: Newer: This one was really tough for me to decide, but ultimately, I think the newer cover is better because it's more mysterious and makes me more curious about the story. Although I like the older cover, it doesn't give me as much of an indication as to what might happen in the story.

Maid of Secrets by Jennifer McGowan

Maid of Secrets (Maids of Honor, #1)Maid of Secrets (Maids of Honor, #1)

My Opinion: Newer: In the newer cover, the girl holding the knife just looks fiercer and more like she'll fit the character in the story. I think there's also more of a contrast and dramatic feel in the newer cover with her being posed next to the queen. 

Which covers do you prefer? :)


  1. I prefer all the old ones except for the last, which I prefer the new one. I guess I like simplicity. Although I prefer the font in general for the newer covers!

    -P.E. @ The Sirenic Codex

  2. This is a hard one! I actually prefer the new on the first one but all the others I think I like the old ones.

  3. I love the old cover for Earthbound. The new cover is cool, but the old one is stunning. I prefer both older covers for Book of Broken Hearts and Dangerous Girls, but I prefer the newer one for Maid of Secrets.

  4. I agree that the newer cover for Dangerous Girls has me more curious...I mean, I already read the book, but the older cover doesn't really show much of what the book is about.

  5. I prefer all the old ones except Maid of Secrets. I usually like the original covers better.

    Rachel @A Perfection Called Books

  6. I agree with your first two, but I like the older cover for Maid of Secrets better. It could be because the newer cover seems a bit crowded to me. I'd have to see it on the book to make a definite decision, though.

    Amber @ Fall Into Books

  7. I agree with all of your choices! Great minds think alike! ;) The new cover for Dangerous Girls is really eerie and striking. I love it!

  8. Dangerous girl; new one! The old one really turns me off from giving it a shot. Maid of secrets; old and new one are both okay, but I think I prefer the new one.


Hi! Thank you so much for commenting, I read each and every comment and love reading them :) Also, I'll comment back as soon as I can. Happy Reading!