Home About Contact Policies Reviews Challenges Giveaways Image Map

Which Cover? #12

Hi everyone! Here's the newest edition of Which Cover?  Here are the recent cover changes that I've found:

Landry Park by Bethany Hagen
Landry Park (Landry Park, #1)Landry Park
My Opinion: Older: Although I like how vibrant the newer cover is, the older one stands out more to me.

Vitro by Jessica Khoury

Vitro (Corpus, #2)Vitro

My Opinion: Newer: The purple sunset is so gorgeous and the cover still manages to reflect the book being set on an island.

The Treatment by Suzanne Young

The Treatment (The Program, #2)The Treatment (The Program, #2)

My Opinion: Older: I haven't read these books yet, but the new cover for The Treatment looks very similar to the cover for The Program. The older cover still has a similar design, but it differentiates itself from the first book, which I think works better.

This Song Will Save Your Life by Leila Sales

This Song Will Save Your LifeThis Song Will Save Your Life

My Opinion: Both: My favorite aspect of the older cover is how "love" is spelled out in the title. The new cover is so striking, though, and I think it'll appeal to a broader audience.

Which covers do you like better? :)


  1. I can go either or with This Song Will Save Your Life. I think they both look great. ;) I like the old Landry Park, because the new one just looks typical of YA books (gowns), and since I've never been a fan of those, I definitely like the old.

  2. Definitely the first cover for Vitro. As for the others...I don't know, I really like them all. I think I like the first Landry Park best and the first Treatment best.
    I do like how love is spelled out in the last cover, something I didn't notice before now! But I agree, I think the second cover is more appealing.

  3. I don't like the new Treatment cover, it looks strange. I like both of the This Song Will Save Your Life covers :) I always love reading these posts, nice picks!

  4. I like both covers for This Song Will Save Your Life too; I might be a bit more partial to the new one though.

  5. I love the newer Vitro cover, those colors are so pretty! I love the older ones for Landry Park and The Treatment and I could go either way with This Song Will Save Your Life :)

  6. I had no idea any of these covers had been changed. Part of me wants to say older for all just because I dislike cover changes but the new Vitro is so pretty and This Song Will Save Your Life might be easier to sell to boys with that cover.

  7. I only knew of one of these cover changes, but this game sure is fun!
    Like you, I like the older cover of Landry Park. Much more eye catching and unique, in today's market.
    For Vitro, the newer one for sure! It's just so gorgeous, but still retains a bit of the original in the title.
    For the Treatment, I disagree. I really don't like the older one - don't like the pose, or the grey color. I love the new one - the empty room, just the two of them, standing like puppets, colorful still.
    As for This Song Will Save Your Life... the original is my fave. It's just SO pretty. Honestly, I'm not a big fan of the new one. It's not ugly, but I wouldn't have picked it up in a bookstore, either.

  8. I like the newer Landry Park and Vitro covers better, although the older covers look good also....Definitely like The Treatment and This Song Will Save Your Life's older covers better!

    Em @

  9. I think I lean toward the new Landry Park cover. Something about it just sticks out a bit more, but I do love the older cover as well. I definitely like the new Vitro cover better. It is really pretty. I think the original has more to do with what I know of the story, but I haven't read it so I don't know for sure. I still like the new one better, anyway! I am not really a fan of any of The Program series covers. They just aren't my style I reckon. As for This Song Will Save Your Life (which is a MUST READ for me, as soon as possible), I genuinely love both of the covers. I don't have a preference either way, which is incredibly strange. But they just both.... well, they rock! I love them!

  10. Sigh, such gorgeous covers. <3 VITRO. I adored that book. I love both covers so much. But the new one might be my favorite :) So so gorgeous. And This Song Will Save Your Life. I think I like the first one the most, but not sure ;p Thank you for sharing about them all. <3

  11. I like the new Landry Park best. The others. Can't really say which one I like better. Not to big on any of them.

  12. I'm so happy with the new cover from This song will save your life. It appeals much more to me and I love the vibrant colors against the dark background.

  13. I'm not too fond of the new The Treatment cover. I actually like the old old cover for it, the one with the orange pill on the tray with the shadows looking down. I think that one suits the series covers more, and the gray-ish one on the inside of the hardcover. I really like the new Landry Park cover, but I'm unsure with This Song... and Vitro.


Hi! Thank you so much for commenting, I read each and every comment and love reading them :) Also, I'll comment back as soon as I can. Happy Reading!